WE'VE MOVED!


As part of our big, new redesign of the Alliance for Justice website, the Justice Watch blog has moved. To be sure you're getting all the latest news about the fight for a fairer America, visit us at www.afj.org/blog
Showing posts with label senate rules reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label senate rules reform. Show all posts

Thursday, November 21, 2013

AFJ commends Senate for changing rules

So many people wanted to know our take on this that it crashed our website for awhile, so we posted our statement on today's rules reform victory here.  But the site is back up and you can find out more about Senate rules reform and the D.C. Circuit at www.afj.org

WASHINGTON, D.C., November 21, 2013 – Alliance for Justice President Nan Aron issued the following statement in response to today’s vote to change the rules of the Senate: 

Alliance for Justice commends Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and the Senators who voted to change Senate rules today for their courageous decision to end the unprecedented abuse of Senate rules by a Republican minority dedicated to obstruction-at-all-costs.

This was not a decision made easily or taken lightly. There was no choice. The Republican minority had turned the existing rules into weapons of mass obstruction. Most recently, they acknowledged that they had no grounds to oppose on the merits President Obama’s supremely-qualified nominees for the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals. But they filibustered those nominees anyway.

This change in the rules is the only way to return the Senate to its place as the world’s greatest deliberative body; it is the only way to ensure that the Senate can put the well-being of the American people ahead of the political interests of an extremist minority.

Now that the rules have changed, the Senate must move quickly to confirm President Obama’s D.C. Circuit nominees, and all of the other nominees that, until now, have been held hostage to obstruction. Those nominees include 14 more nominees for judgeships who are currently awaiting Senate floor votes, and executive branch nominees such as Rep. Mel Watt, D-N.C., whose nomination to run the Federal Housing Finance Agency was filibustered last month.

Tuesday, July 16, 2013

AFJ: Reported agreement on Obama nominees "an important step forward"

               Alliance for Justice President Nan Aron released the following statement today in response to media reports of an agreement concerning seven of President Obama’s executive branch nominations:

                The agreement, as described in media accounts, is an important step forward for the United States Senate and for the American people whose interests are served when government functions.  But it is not the end of the story.  There will be more legislation, more executive nominations and judicial nominees upon which the Senate will need to act over the next several months.  We hope the spirit of this agreement carries over to that business as well.  But if it does not, all options remain on the table for allowing the Senate to evolve in ways that make it a more effective institution.

              Today’s events demonstrate what can happen when a strong, unified, principled stand is taken against obstruction and dysfunction, and we will work hard to ensure that this same sense of purpose and firm resolve will be present when judicial nominations and vital legislation make their way to the Senate floor in the coming months.

            If this agreement fails to cure the culture of obstruction, we will fight for the reforms necessary to end the paralyzing gridlock that has characterized the Senate over the last several months.
 
         

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

Nan Aron on "The Broken Senate"

This is AFJ President Nan Aron's statement for today's forum at the National Press Club called "Fixing the Broken Senate: Restoring Democracy and Fixing the Filibuster."  

 ●Watch video of the forum at www.afj.org 
 ● Read more about Senate rules reform

Alliance for Justice is very pleased to be a part of this discussion about the “Broken Senate.” I feel like we’re coming to the end of the fifth season of a bad reality show.

Nan Aron
But what’s happening in the Senate is not fiction. It’s very real. The abuse of the filibuster has become a threat to the proper functioning of the government and to public faith in the institution of the Senate.  A recent poll by The Economist put the approval rate of Congress at nine percent. That’s incredible, but not really surprising.  It does make me wonder who those nine percent are. Family members? Campaign consultants?

It’s deplorable that the American people have so little regard for a crucial part of our government. It’s unhealthy for our democracy. And I don’t think there is any question that at least part of the problem has been the rampant misuse of the filibuster in the Senate, which has led to stalemate and gridlock in spite of the enormous problems the country now faces.

Let me be clear about something: The filibuster has a legitimate role when used responsibly. But we have entered an era of unprecedented abuse of rules and traditions, which is forcing the Senate to the brink of drastic action. The filibuster traditionally has been used to allow a minority to make a principled stand on matters of enormous and unusual importance.  It forces the process to slow down and helps ensure that all voices are heard. It’s a signal that something of significance is at stake. But that’s not what’s happening now.

This is the crucial point to understand.  As the motivation behind the filibuster has changed and its frequency increased, its legitimacy has declined. The fights over President Obama’s judicial nominees, for instance, are not ideological in any real sense. The president has gone out of his way to nominate men and women from the legal and political mainstream. Who could honestly say that the filibuster of Caitlin Halligan was some kind of titanic ideological fight?

Today’s filibusters are just crass politics. They reflect a desire to block the president’s agenda at every turn and feed the insatiable need of a hyper-partisan political base for endless obstruction. We’re in an era where one side believes cooperation is a dirty word—or an invitation to a primary challenge. When that intransigent attitude is paired with a procedural weapon as potent as the filibuster, gridlock is the result.  And that’s what makes the situation different today from what it has been in the past. And that’s why the nuclear option is back on the table.


Serious talk about changing the rules has been reborn because the filibuster has evolved from a                            
targeted tool to a weapon of indiscriminate disruption. The entire legislative process is now held captive to this threat. We’ve gotten to the point where just the threat of a filibuster is enough to derail the Senate. The abuse of the process has created a de facto threshold of 60 votes for action—a supermajority requirement for everyday business that can be found nowhere in the Constitution.

It’s important to remember that the problem isn’t just that bills and nominations with clear majorities are stopped, but that many nominations are never made and bills are never proposed, even though they could achieve a simple majority if they were given a chance. There is an invisible price for gridlock that the public never sees.

Obviously, the first test will come in the next few days when cloture petitions are expected to be filed on a series of executive branch nominees—Richard Cordray, Tom Perez, Gina McCarthy, and nominees for the National Labor Relations Board. What happens to these highly qualified nominees will set the tone for the rest of this Congress. If Republicans continue their current behavior and prevent final votes, then the choices will be narrowed to two options: allow crucial agencies that deal with hugely important issues to be left leaderless or reform the rules to permit up-or-down votes.

But the battle over executive nominees is just the beginning. The next big fight looming later this summer is over the President’s three nominees to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals.  This is a case of the Republicans engaging in what will be a kind of Group Filibuster, where they don’t even pretend to care about the qualifications or ideologies of the individual nominees.  They just don’t want anyone appointed by President Obama to this crucial court no matter who they are.

Senator Grassley has complained that the President is trying to “pack the court,” as if filling vacant judgeships is some kind of unprecedented power grab. Republicans pretend to be outraged that the president has sent names forward for empty seats on the 11-member D.C. Circuit--just like every other president has done since the Grover Cleveland administration. This would be laughable if the consequences weren’t so serious.

Of course, we know why the Republicans will threaten to filibuster Patricia Millett, Nina Pillard, and Robert Wilkins. The D.C. Circuit is the federal appeals court that most closely oversees the actions of federal agencies on topics like the environment, consumer protections, workers’ rights, banking regulations, and other vital issues. Those are the same issues, by the way, that are at stake in the current executive nominations fights.  In some ways, the two big summer battles over executive and judicial nominations are really one big fight over the future of the country. Fair enough. But the question is, will the Senate be permitted to bring these issues to a final vote on the merits, or will procedural hurdles be erected to prevent democracy from functioning.

So at some point in the next several months, when the three DC Circuit nominees reach the floor, the Senate will have to make another set of choices, just like the ones it will start to face next week on executive nominations. Either accept the obstructionism of a hyper-partisan minority or change the rules to allow the President and the Senate to do the jobs the Constitution demands of them.

For those who care about our democracy and the courts, the choice is easy.

The American people are saying enough is enough. The time for reform is rapidly approaching.

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

At hearing for ATF nominee, more Republican obstruction

On Tuesday, the Senate Judiciary Committee held a high-profile hearing on President Obama’s nominee to head the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, B. Todd Jones.    Jones is an exceptionally qualified nominee.  He currently serves as both the acting director of ATF and as the U.S. Attorney for the District of Minnesota (a position for which he was unanimously approved by the Judiciary Committee in 2009).

B. Todd Jones
Though ATF plays a critical law enforcement role, including involvement in investigating tragedies like the Sandy Hook school shootings, the Boston Marathon bombing, and the industrial explosion in West, Texas, the agency has not had a permanent director since 2006 – that’s when the law was changed to require Senate confirmation That sad reality may continue, as Republican questions at the  hearing suggest that they may continue to obstruct executive nominees as a way to prevent agencies they don’t like from functioning.

Many Republican questions raised tangential concerns about Jones’s record.  For instance, the Committee’s ranking member, Sen. Charles Grassley (R-Iowa)—yes, the very same senator who wants to get rid of three judicial seats on the second most important court in the country, the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals—pressed Jones to answer for a botched ATF operation, Fast and Furious.  But Jones  actually was brought in to clean up after the fact.

Moreover, just before the hearing ended, there was a telling exchange between Grassley and Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.).  Sen. Grassley requested that the hearing record remain open for longer than the normal one week period, based on the expectation that  there were “a lot of things that could come up.”  Senator Klobuchar agreed to keep it open for two weeks.  Sensing dissatisfaction in Grassley’s reaction, she asked, “What would you like?”  Senator Grassley responded, “Until we get done with this whole [thing].”  While the senators’ quick negotiation seemed to be good-spirited, it sounds like  Sen. Grassley has no interest in quickly moving Jones’s nomination to the Senate floor.  This stonewalling is particularly hypocritical in light of repeated Republican statements that we don’t need new gun laws, we just need to “enforce the laws on the books.”  

Of course, Jones is just one of a slew of highly qualified Obama nominees that Republicans so farhave refused to confirm because they disapprove of the organization itself (see EPA Administrator nominee Gina McCarthy, CFPB director nominee Richard Cordray, Labor Secretary nominee Tom Perez, and three NLRB nominees.  If Republicans continue to hold agencies hostage by unfairly blocking confirmations, the Senate majority should revisit reforming Senate rules.


Consumer Financial Protection Bureau strikes blow against forced arbitration

For many of us it may be the most important contract we ever sign.  It’s the contract that sets the terms for what often is our single largest investment – our home.

Richard Cordray
But what happens if the bank that holds our mortgage tries to cheat?  What if they improperly hide fees, or raise rates or even try to foreclose on the property illegally?  Banks have sought to protect themselves by inserting “forced arbitration” clauses into mortgages and home equity loans.

As we’ve noted previously on this Blog, under forced arbitration, consumers who buy defective products or are overcharged for services are barred from taking their cases to court.  Instead, they must use a private arbitration firm chosen and paid for by the business itself.  These clauses also often ban class actions, which allow individuals to band together to bring their common claims.

Having a dispute settled by arbitration is like playing a baseball game in which the other team hires, fires – and pays – the umpires.  One study of top arbitrators for one major arbitration firm found that they rule for the corporations that hire them 93.8 percent of the time.

One of the reasons we refer to the current Supreme Court majority as “The 1% Court” is its enthusiasm for inflicting forced arbitration on consumers.

But Congress drew the line at home mortgages.  Section 1414 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act bans forced arbitration in mortgage disputes.  Regulations implementing the law had to be issued by an agency created by that law – the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.  Those regulations took effect June 1. Section 1028 of the Act also mandates that the CFPB study and report to Congress on “the use of agreements providing for arbitration . . . in connection with the offering or providing of consumer products or financial services.”

You remember the CFPB.  That’s the agency Republicans hate so much that they’ve vowed to filibuster anyone President Obama nominates to run it unless the President agrees to eviscerate Wall Street reform.  That includes the current agency director, Richard Cordray, named to the position through a recess appointment that was called into question by a ruling of the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals.

The new forced arbitration regulation makes clear what this fight and the other fights over President Obama’s nominees really are all about.  They're about Republicans who can’t stand Wall Street reform or consumer protection or anything that gives everyday Americans a fighting chance against corporate special interests.

That’s why the fights ahead over Cordray, and President Obama’s nominees to the D.C. Circuit and his  nominees for posts like Secretary of Labor, Environmental Protection Agency Administrator and the National Labor Relations Board, are so important.  That’s why, if Senate Republicans refuse to allow yes-or-no votes on these nominees, the Senate majority needs to revisit reforming Senate rules.

Monday, June 10, 2013

This Week in History: Republicans use threat of "nuclear option" to confirm conservative judges to D.C. Circuit and other appellate courts

Over the past week, a chorus of congressional Republicans has criticized President Obama for fulfilling his constitutional duty to nominate qualified individuals for the three open seats on the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, the second-highest court in the land.  Eight years ago this week, they were singing a far different tune.

On May 23, 2005, the so-called Senate “Gang of 14” agreement set the stage for up-or-down votes on a number of extremely conservative Republican judicial nominees. That agreement paid almost immediate dividends for a slate of conservative judges, particularly during this week in 2005.

On June 8, 2005, the Senate confirmed Janice Rogers Brown – who once referred to the onset of the New Deal as the “triumph of our own socialist revolution” – to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals. The next day, the Senate confirmed William Pryor to the 11th Circuit; among other things, Pryor had defended Alabama’s power to execute juveniles and the mentally retarded as the state’s Attorney General. Less than a week later, on June 14, the Senate confirmed Thomas Griffith to the D.C. Circuit. In all, five circuit court judges were confirmed within a week, two of whom still sit on our nation’s second most important court – the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Today, Republicans have engaged in all manner of obstructionism to prevent President Obama’s highly qualified and diverse judicial nominees from ever taking the bench. Nowhere is this more apparent than the D.C. Circuit. Caitlin Halligan was filibustered twice before asking the President to withdraw her nomination, even after she received the American Bar Association’s highest possible rating of unanimously well qualified.
Sri Srinivasan waited nearly a year before he was unanimously confirmed to the D.C. Circuit last month.

Now, Republicans have pushed forward a bill to reduce the size of the D.C. Circuit by three seats, seeking to deny President Obama any opportunity to install judges with a clear respect for the rule of law on a court that is currently dominated by radical conservatives.  Although the confirmations of Janice Rogers Brown and Thomas Griffith brought the D.C. Circuit’s membership to 11 judges, Republicans have apparently decided that with President Obama in office, eight is enough.

President Obama has nominated three highly qualified, uncontroversial nominees to the D.C. Circuit. At the same moment in President George W. Bush’s second term, facing a lower court workload, Republicans threatened to change the rules in order to fill all 11 seats on the D.C. Circuit. While the nominees put forward by President Bush were hyper-partisan, President Obama’s nominees have a clear record of exceptional qualifications and should be swiftly confirmed.

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

AFJ: There is no excuse for delaying Obama D.C. Circuit nominees

Alliance for Justice President Nan Aron issued the following statement today concerning President Obama’s nominations of Patricia Ann Millett, Cornelia Pillard and Robert Wilkins to serve on the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit:

Nan Aron
We applaud President Obama for nominating supremely qualified individuals to the three vacancies on the D.C. Circuit, the nation’s second most important court, and we commend him for sending a bold, public signal that these nominees are a top priority.   These choices also reflect the president’s outstanding record for increasing diversity on the federal bench.  We were pleased to stand with the President at today’s announcement, and we are pleased to stand with him in his effort to fill these seats.  Now Senators must fulfill their constitutional duty by swiftly reviewing and voting yes or no on these nominations.

There is no excuse for delay.  The D.C. Circuit decides cases that affect every aspect of all Americans’ lives, from the air we breathe to workplace safety to the health of our families to the ability to regulate financial institutions.  This court needs to be at full strength in order to manage its critically important caseload, the unique nature of which may well affect the ability of the government to serve the public interest.

 With stakes this high, we are prepared to join with President Obama as he champions the effort to ensure that the Senate fulfills its constitutional obligation to fill the circuit’s ninth, 10th and 11th seats without delay — just as it did during President George W. Bush’s administration.  There has never been a more important time for all who care about the future of our country to mobilize against the destructive tactics of obstruction that have wounded our courts and damaged public confidence in our democratic institutions.

●Read Nan Aron’s column about the D.C. Circuit in The Huffington Post.
●Watch Nan Aron discuss the D.C. Circuit with Melissa Harris Perry on MSNBC
●Read more about the D.C. Circuit.

Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Things Fall Apart: the Gang of 14 Eight Years Later

by Michelle D. Schwartz, Director of Justice Programs

As talk increasingly turns to Harry Reid’s potential invocation of the “nuclear option” to do away with the filibuster – at least on nominations – as early as July, it’s tempting to think back to the last time we heard such atomic language in the U.S. Senate.

It was 2005, and then-Majority Leader Bill Frist, frustrated by the filibusters of some of President George W. Bush’s judicial nominees by a then-Democratic minority, threatened to change the Senate rules through a simple majority vote.

What happened next is now Senate folklore:  eight years ago this week, a Gang of 14 rode in on horseback and saved the Senate from itself.

Or did they?

The Gang of 14 – seven Democrats and seven Republicans – agreed to filibuster judicial nominees only in “extraordinary circumstances.”  But an analysis of contested cloture votes on judicial nominations over the past eight years shows that, when push came to shove, only the Democrats in the Gang of 14 defined “extraordinary” in a way that’s recognizable to ordinary Americans.

Click to see full size
As the chart above shows, all seven Democratic members of the Gang of 14 served for the remaining 3 ½ years of President George W. Bush’s term.  During that period:
  • There were six contested cloture votes on judicial nominees, meaning the Democratic Gang of 14ers had 42 opportunities to weigh in on contested cloture votes for judicial nominees.
  • In all of those votes, there were only two no votes by Gang of 14 Democrats.
  • No Democratic member of the Gang of 14 voted no more than once—and five Democrats never voted no.
The remaining Republican Gang of 14ers’ votes during the Obama Administration tell a vastly different story.  There are only four Republican members of the Gang of 14 who have served for some portion of President Obama’s almost 4 ½ years in office.  During that period:
  • There have been eight contested cloture votes on judicial nominees (two on Caitlin Halligan).
  • The Republican Gang of 14ers have had 31 opportunities to weigh in on contested cloture votes for judicial nominees.  (Senator Snowe retired at the end of the 112th Congress; as a result, she was not present for the second cloture vote on Caitlin Halligan.)
  • Republican members of the Gang of 14 have voted no on cloture in 15 of those 31 cases—nearly 50 percent.
  • Every Republican Gang of 14er has voted no at least three times.
Now, some have argued that the Gang of 14 agreement only applied to the remainder of the 109th Congress, which ended at the beginning of 2007.  However, the Democratic members of the Gang didn’t operate that way.  On October 24, 2007 – well into the 110th Congress – six out of seven of them voted to invoke cloture on now-Fifth Circuit Judge Leslie Southwick’s nomination, even though the majority of Democrats voted no and Southwick only garnered 62 votes for cloture.

More importantly, if even the most purportedly reasonable and moderate Republicans of eight years ago cannot be counted on today, how can we possibly expect to see forward movement in the Senate?
We will see critical tests in the coming weeks and months, not only on judicial nominations, but also on the President’s nominations to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the Department of Labor, the Environmental Protection Agency, and the National Labor Relations Board.  It’s high time for Republicans to show that they are willing and able to staff the very institutions that allow our democracy to function.

Otherwise, it looks like more and more Senate Democrats are waking up to the realization that unilateral disarmament – like the Gang of 14 and the failed “handshake agreement” from earlier this year – leaves you in a precarious position during a nuclear standoff.

Monday, May 20, 2013

Democracy on trial in the Senate


Republicans seek to obstruct Obama
executive, judicial nominees

Nan Aron
By Nan Aron
President, 
Alliance for Justice

            With battles ahead over President Obama’s choices for Secretary of Labor, Environmental Protection Agency Administrator, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Director and the National Labor Relations Board, and fights over the nation’s second most important court likely to follow, democracy itself is on trial in the United States Senate.

            If Republicans persist in preventing yes-or-no votes on President Obama’s executive and judicial nominees, the only recourse will be for the majority to revisit Senate rules reform and put an end once and for all to Republican efforts to subvert the Senate’s constitutional obligation to provide advice and consent.
 
Richard Cordray
        The first test is likely to come this week. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid says he will schedule a vote on President Obama’s nominee to lead the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Richard Cordray.  The CFPB was created as part of the Wall Street Reform law as an agency solely devoted to protecting consumers of financial products from mortgages to credit cards.  In a transparent effort to protect the very special interests that collapsed our economy and brought ruin to so many Americans, Republicans so far have refused to confirm Cordray. In fact, Republicans have said they won’t confirm anyone to run the CFPB.

            Republicans have been equally obstinate about the president’s nominees for the National Labor Relations Board, the independent agency charged with protecting the rights of workers – and a hearing on those nominees just last week showed no thaw in that obstinacy.  That’s why Cordray and some of the current NLRB members had to be named through recess appointments.

            But three Republican-appointed judges of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, breaking with decades of precedent, decided that the President doesn’t have the power to make such recess appointments.  The decision is part of a pattern in which the D.C. Circuit consistently sides with corporate interests over workers and consumers – blocking Wall Street reforms, undermining labor rights, and rolling back environmental protections.

            So it’s no wonder that Republicans also are trying to prevent the president from restoring balance to the D.C. Circuit, which is currently dominated by Republican appointees.  The latest underhanded tactic from Republican Senators amounts to a ‘pre-emptive filibuster’ – an effort to eliminate three of the four vacant judgeships on the court in order to prevent President Obama from filling those seats.

Tom Perez
          But even that isn’t the end of the obstruction.  We are pleased that two Senate committees were able to overcome Republican stalling tactics and vote last week in favor of President Obama’s highly-qualified nominees to lead the Department of Labor and the Environmental Protection Agency.  The next step must be swift yes-or-no votes by the full Senate on the nominations of Tom Perez and Gina McCarthy.

            Unfortunately, these two outstanding nominees’ ordeals may be far from over.  All of the Republicans on both committees voted no.  As AFJ has pointed out before, to Senate Republicans, one of the only things as bad as a Labor Secretary who will protect working people is an Environmental Protection Agency administrator who will protect the environment.

           A solid majority of voters twice has made clear that they support the approach to government taken by Barack Obama.  In response, the Republican strategy boils down to rule-or-ruin.  They have shown themselves prepared to paralyze government, no matter what the cost to the American people.  In the days ahead, we will see if the Senate is ready to break free of this paralysis.

Thursday, May 16, 2013

Grassley deserves "A" for creativity, "F" for content on "pre-emptive filibuster" of D.C. Circuit nominees


Sen. Charles Grassley (R-Iowa) deserves “an ‘A’ for creativity but an ‘F’ for content” for his scheme to obstruct future nominees to the nation’s second most important court, Alliance for Justice President Nan Aron said Thursday.

Aron was referring to Grassley’s plan to eliminate three of the four vacant judgeships on the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, a plan he raised again at a Senate Judiciary Committee meeting Thursday.

During that meeting, the committee voted in favor of president Obama’s nomination of Sri Srinivasan to fill one of four vacancies on the 11-judge court.  “But don’t be fooled: Today’s vote by no means shows Republicans’ willingness to stop playing games with the president’s nominees.  During the same meeting, Grassley announced what amounts to a ‘pre-emptive filibuster,' declaring his intent to eliminate the other three vacancies on the D.C. Circuit, effectively blocking any nominees to those seats,” Aron said.

Grassley cited what he claimed is a light workload for the court, based solely on the number of cases handled by each judge.  “That claim is as nonsensical as it is hypocritical,” Aron said.

Patricia Wald
“As the court’s former Chief Judge, Patricia Wald, has written, ‘The D.C. Circuit hears the most complex, time-consuming, labyrinthine disputes over regulations with the greatest impact on ordinary Americans’ lives . . . . These cases can require thousands of hours of preparation by the judges, often consuming days of argument, involving hundreds of parties and interveners, and necessitating dozens of briefs and thousands of pages of record – all of which culminates in lengthy, technically intricate legal opinions.’”

Aron also noted that “less than a week ago, at another meeting of the same committee, Sen. Grassley’s close Republican ally, Sen. Jeff Sessions said it was wrong to measure caseload by raw numbers without factoring in complexity.

“The hypocrisy is clear when one looks at Sen. Grassley’s own record.  When the caseload on the court was lighter than it is now, Sen. Grassley supported President George W. Bush’s nominees to fill all eleven seats on the court.

“The current majority on the D.C. Circuit has used its power to issue decisions undermining protections for workers, consumers, and the environment that affect all Americans,” Aron said. “Sen. Grassley and his allies are using every trick in the book to try to keep it that way.”

“If the Republican obsession with obstruction persists,” Aron said, “then the Senate majority must reform Senate rules to allow the will of the majority of Americans to prevail.”

Read more about the D.C. Circuit 
Read more about Grassley’s plan 

Thursday, May 9, 2013

Republicans turn Senate rules, traditions into weapons of mass obstruction


Republican obstruction of the president’s nominees on the Senate floor through use of (often silent) filibusters has been well-documented, but in the past two days the public has seen what those of us working on judicial nominees have known for far too long – the obstruction is often just as bad at the committee level.

Gina McCarthy
Just one day after using an arcane procedural maneuver to delay a committee vote on the nomination of Tom Perez to serve as Secretary of Labor, Senate Republicans have used another underhanded ploy to delay a committee vote on the nomination of Gina McCarthy to lead the Environmental Protection Agency.  They boycotted a meeting of the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works to prevent the Committee from even holding a vote.  Committee Republicans could hardly argue they lacked sufficient information to form an opinion on McCarthy – she answered more than 1,000 questions from committee members.

On one level this behavior is understandable.  To Senate Republicans, one of the only things as bad as a Labor Secretary who will protect working people is an Environmental Protection Agency administrator who will protect the environment.  But the brazen nature of these committee delay tactics is shocking nonetheless.

Unfortunately, in the context of judicial nominations, such committee delays have become commonplace – and start even earlier in the process.  By committee tradition,* the Senate Judiciary Committee typically won’t hold a hearing on a judicial nominee unless both home-state senators agree to allow the nomination to move forward.    Like any such tradition, it works only as long as it is not exploited.  But that is exactly what Senate Republicans are doing now.

That means some judicial nominees are stuck in limbo waiting for Judiciary Committee hearings months or years after they were nominated.  In many more cases, the White House – reluctant to impose that fate on nominees – is left waiting in vain for Republican home-state senators to help identify acceptable candidates.

And, coming full circle, hanging over all of this obstruction at the committee level (and sometimes before) is the knowledge that even if nominees survive those obstacles, they face the specter of the filibuster once they reach the floor.  The events of the past two days make clear, once again, that the weak-kneed agreement on Senate rules reached in January cannot come close to constraining the Republicans’ willingness to turn rules and traditions into weapons of mass obstruction.  The Senate needs to back to the drawing board and enact tough-minded rules reform now.

Read more about obstruction by Senate Republicans:
*-Although this tradition has been in place to some degree for many years, not all Judiciary Committee chairmen have been as generous as the current one in waiting for both home-state senators to indicate assent before holding a hearing.

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Halligan cloture vote shows Republican senators are addicted to obstruction

UPDATE: AFJ President Nan Aron discusses the filibuster of Caitlin Halligan on the March 9 edition of MSNBC's Up With Chris Hayes:


Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

In the previous post to this blog, we said that today's cloture vote on the nomination of Caitlin Halligan for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit would tell us if Senate rules reform is for real.

A short time ago, we got the answer.  Here is AFJ President Nan Aron's statement concerning the defeat of the cloture motion:

Caitlin Halligan
Earlier this week, we urged Republican senators finally to put partisanship and obstruction aside and vote for cloture on the nomination of Caitlin Halligan to serve on the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals.

But it appears that urging Republican senators to rise above partisanship is like urging three-pack-a-day smokers to “just say no” to tobacco.

 Today, Republican Senators proved themselves to be addicted to obstruction, and utterly uninterested in putting the needs of the American people ahead of partisan posturing.

 As a result, for the second time in two years, Americans have been denied the services of a highly qualified nominee to serve on what is widely considered the nation’s second most important court.

There is no justification for this level of opposition.  Halligan’s nomination has strong bipartisan support, including endorsements from the National District Attorneys Association, the New York State Sheriff’s Association and two former assistants to Solicitors General under Republican administrations.  Her credentials are impeccable and she was rated “well qualified” by the American Bar Association. 

 The vote today also makes clear that the recent agreement to ‘reform’ Senate rules really was no agreement at all, but rather a blank check for continued obstruction.  We believe the Senate majority needs to reconsider the terms of this agreement, and revisit serious rules reform.

One could argue that Caitlin Halligan was the victim of partisan obstruction, but it’s more than that: the American people are the victims.  Not only is a well-qualified nominee once again in limbo, the D.C. Circuit will continue to limp along with four of its 11 seats vacant.

Monday, March 4, 2013

They're trying to filibuster Caitlin Halligan again


Now we find out if Senate rules reform is for real

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid tonight filed a motion for cloture on the nomination of Caitlin Halligan for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. A vote is expected Wednesday morning.
 
Click here to find out how you can help get Caitlin Halligan confirmed

And here's AFJ President Nan Aron's statement:

This week, we find out if the agreement reached at the start of the current session to reform Senate rules has any real meaning.

Without question, Caitlin Halligan is extraordinarily well qualified for a seat on the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals. Her nomination has strong bipartisan support.

The fact that a minority of senators could stop a highly-qualified nominee like Caitlin Halligan in 2011 is a classic example of the misuse of the filibuster for partisan gain that has characterized the current Senate minority.  President Obama has renominated Halligan, but Republicans are threatening a filibuster once again.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid has filed a motion for cloture. If the motion fails and Republicans succeed in filibustering Halligan for the second time in as many years, it will make clear that the recent agreement to “reform” Senate rules really was no agreement at all, but rather a blank check for continued obstruction.

We urge senators finally to put partisanship and obstruction aside and vote for cloture.

Click here to find out more about Caitlin Halligan and the D.C. Circuit.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

AFJ Responds to agreement on Senate rules reform



WASHINGTON, D.C.,  January 24, 2013 — Alliance for Justice President Nan Aron issued the following statement on today’s agreement concerning reforming the rules of the United States Senate:

Today’s agreement to enact incremental reforms to Senate rules, while containing some provisions that may prove to be of significant value in mitigating the calamitous mistreatment of judicial nominations, does not go as far as we would like in the direction of meaningful change on the broader issues confronting our country.

While we are particularly happy to see long-overdue changes to the rules governing filibusters of district court nominees, we remain disappointed that circuit court nominations remain subject to the kind of destructive obstruction that has characterized President Obama’s first term. Limiting post-cloture debate to two hours serves as an implicit acknowledgement of the unprecedented degree to which Republicans have inappropriately used procedural weapons to delay and derail these important nominations. This agreement holds out hope that some degree of comity may now return to the Senate for district court nominees, but at the same time we urge Senate leaders to use every tool at their disposal to prevent the widespread obstruction of circuit court nominees that has characterized the past four years.

Although we had hoped for a more robust package, we are encouraged by the spirit of reform and activism led by Sens. Jeff Merkley, Tom Udall, and Tom Harkin, carried forward by dozens of organizations, and given voice by hundreds of thousands of Americans, hungry for progress, who contacted their senators to demand change. The American people deserve a Senate that is willing and able to tackle the great issues that confront the nation, and we will watch diligently in the days ahead to see whether today’s agreement is sufficient to ensure that is the case.

Monday, January 21, 2013

Huffington Post asks AFJ, CWA to write about ending gridlock

As part of a series on President Obama's second term, The Huffington Post commissioned a special column from Alliance for Justice President Nan Aron and Larry Cohen, president of the Communications Workers of America, on ending gridlock.  Their solution: real reform of Senate rules:

Ending Congressional Gridlock Requires
Curbing Abuse of the Filibuster
 
Jefferson Smith, the fictional filibustering senator in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, has captivated the imaginations of many Americans. But when was the last time a senator took a principled stand in the form of an around-the-clock speech, then collapsed with exhaustion, having convinced the crooked political establishment to mend its misguided ways?

Now is the time to stop looking to a 73-year-old Hollywood movie for inspiration and start fixing the way the Senate does business so that a latter-day Mr. Smith can actually take a stand for genuine matters of principle. There's growing momentum to end legislative obstruction by changing the rules when the new Senate reconvenes later this month. Sens. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.) and Tom Udall (D-N.M.) have introduced Senate Resolutions 4 and 6, which mirror the filibuster reforms supported by Fix the Senate Now, a coalition of 50 progressive organizations. And Democrats have the votes to revamp the rules.
 

Friday, January 11, 2013

We can fix the Senate – with your help



We’ve stepped up our campaign for Senate rules reform with a petition drive.  Please sign our petition urging Senators to cosponsor Senate Resolution 4.  The resolution makes several key changes to Senate rules to end the unprecedented obstruction that has brought the business of the Senate almost to a halt.
 
One piece of progressive legislation after another has been killed by filibuster.  Scores of judicial nominations have been delayed – and now some Republicans may use the filibuster against President Obama’s Cabinet nominees.

Without rules reform, the gridlock continues. That means the fate of almost every other big issue before Congress – from gun control to who sits on the federal bench to who leads the most important agencies in the executive branch - may depend on the outcome of the rules reform fight.


Get more information:

Thursday, January 3, 2013

UPDATED 2:55PM: Fixing the Senate: Looks like we'll have to keep fighting a little longer

A new Senate convenes today and we think the first order of business should be to fix this:


But Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid will delay bringing up the issue of rules reform until later in the month as he begins negotiations with Minority Leader Mitch McConnell.  Reid can do this and still use the constitutional option (allowing reform to pass with 51 votes) by recessing the Senate after it convenes instead of adjourning it, thereby extending the first legislative day.  As the Fix The Senate Now coalition notes in a statement today:
The decision by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) to enter into direct talks with Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) on curbing the abuse of the filibuster shows the growing strength of the movement for real reform of Senate rules.  
And we can put the time to good use by redoubling our efforts for real reform.

Call your senators now at  1-888-717-0911 and tell them to support real Senate rules reform.  For more information go to www.fixthesenatenow.org 



Friday, December 28, 2012

Make a New Year's resolution to help us fix the Senate


CALL YOUR SENATORS:
1-888-717-0911

Next week brings not just a new year but also a new United States Congress.   Each new Congress has the right to establish its own rules.  And that’s why next week is the best opportunity finally to end the massive Republican obstruction of the work of the United States Senate.

As Jonathan Bernstein explains on the Washington Post Plum Line blog, the widely-quoted figures about cloture votes to end filibusters actually understate the extent of the problem. He writes:  
In the historic 111th Congress, Sen. Mitch McConnell and the Republicans decided to create a 60-vote Senate, which meant that 60 votes were needed on absolutely everything. Which means that they filibustered every single bill, every single nomination, every single amendment, even every single motion, or at least all those for which the Senate rules allowed them to force a 60-vote supermajority. It wasn’t 137 filibusters; it was far, far more.  
Bernstein offers a more detailed primer about how Republicans turned rarely used delaying tactics into weapons of mass obstruction on his own blog.

But we can change all this next week.  Make a New Year’s resolution to ring out the old year and ring in the new by calling your Senators and telling them you want real Senate rules reform. 

CALL YOUR SENATORS: 1-888-717-0911

● We have an overview of the issue on our website
● Hear the media briefing from AFJ President Nan Aron, Larry Cohen of the Communications Workers of America and Michael Brune of the Sierra Club on our YouTube channel.
● There’s much more at www.fixthesenatenow.org

We wish you, and the new United State Senate, a happy and productive New Year.

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Call your Senator today to demand Senate rules reform


We've written often about the failure of the United States Senate to confirm judges.  But that failure is part of a wider failure – the failure of the Senate itself, brought on by the unprecedented misuse of arcane rules and procedures by the Republican minority.

Abuse of the filibuster is prolonging the crisis in our federal courts, giving new meaning to the term “obstruction of justice.”

It’s not only judicial nominations that are at stake.   The filibuster has been abused to derail vital legislation, supported by a majority of the American people, and a majority of U.S. Senators, paralyzing progress on jobs, clean energy, workers’ rights, and immigration.

To an extent unprecedented in American history, 60 votes has become the needed threshold for nearly every order of Senate business. Under the current broken system, senators do not even have to stand up and talk to block a bill.  We believe they should be accountable for their actions.

Senators can fix this problem. Call your senators at 1-888-717-0911 and ask them to reform the rules.  Tell your Senators to support reforms that would:

●  Reduce the time for debate on nominations.

●  Require that if Senators want to filibuster, they have to do it the old-fashioned way – stand up and talk.  Now a Senator can derail a bill merely by saying he or she intends to filibuster.

●  Necessitate 41 votes to keep a filibuster going – instead of requiring the majority to muster 60 votes to stop it.

●  Allow only one filibuster per bill – now even the decision to discuss a bill at all, called a motion to proceed, can be filibustered.


When the next Congress takes office in January, the Senate will have one opportunity to reform the rules with a simple majority vote.  We are already gaining extraordinary momentum and are confident with the outcome this time around.  But we can't do it without you!

We need you to join us in a national day of action to support Senate rules reform. Call 1-888-717-0911  today and ask your senators to support reforms that will ensure that they can debate and vote on the critical issues facing our country.

Thursday, December 13, 2012

The New York Times takes on "a severe breakdown in the process for appointing federal judges"

Making extensive use of AFJ's resources on judicial selection, The New York Times has an excellent editorial on that topic today:

Judges Needed for Federal Courts

There has been a severe breakdown in the process for appointing federal judges. At the start of the Reagan years, it took, on average, a month for candidates for appellate and trial courts to go from nomination to confirmation. In the first Obama term, it has taken, on average, more than seven months.


Seventy-seven judgeships, 9 percent of the federal bench (not counting the Supreme Court), are vacant; 19 more seats are expected to open up soon. The lack of judges is more acute if one considers the growing caseload. The Judicial Conference, the courts’ policy-making body, has recommended expanding the bench by 88 additional judgeships.

President Obama must make fully staffing the federal courts an important part of his second-term agenda — starting with the immediate Senate confirmation of the 18 nominees approved by the Senate Judiciary Committee.

A significant reason for the slowdown has been the partisan opposition of Republicans to appeals court and even to trial court nominations, even though almost none of the nominees have backgrounds that raise ideological issues. The Republicans have time and again used the filibuster, the threat of filibuster, holds on nominations and other tactics to block confirmations.
The Democratic majority, led by Senator Harry Reid, can speed up the process by limiting use of the filibuster. He can do so by pushing for a simple majority vote at the start of the January session to alter Senate rules so that every judicial and executive-branch nominee is assured an up-or-down vote within 90 days. Without that change, many judicial nominations will founder.

The full editorial is available here.