WE'VE MOVED!


As part of our big, new redesign of the Alliance for Justice website, the Justice Watch blog has moved. To be sure you're getting all the latest news about the fight for a fairer America, visit us at www.afj.org/blog
Showing posts with label medical device safety act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medical device safety act. Show all posts

Friday, August 27, 2010

Injured Patients Likely Lack a Legal Recourse for Their Injuries

The New York Times reports that once again patients have been injured by FDA-approved products. Unfortunately, these patients, like thousands of others harmed by other FDA-approved devices, will likely have no legal recourse for their injuries as a result of the U.S. Supreme Court’s February 2008 Riegel v. Medtronic, Inc. decision.

In Riegel, the Court immunized medical device manufacturers from lawsuits by patients who are injured by defective premarket approval medical devices. The Court reached this result by deciding such claims are barred by a preemption clause included in the Medical Device Amendments of 1976, and the hope that approval by the FDA will adequately protect patients from unsafe medical devices. Unfortunately, as the New York Times reminds us, patients continue to suffer serious injuries from defective FDA-approved devices.

The Riegel decision bypasses congressional intent and the past thirty years of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) playing a complementary role with tort liability in protecting consumers. Tell Congress to enact the Medical Device Safety Act in order to fix this glaring unjustice.

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

American Children Are Suffering; It is Time to Pass the Medical Device Safety Act

A new study by Pediatrics, the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics, is raising new questions about the safety of medical devices in children. Congress should respond by passing legislation restoring the right to hold medical device manufacturers accountable in state court when they manufacture defective products.

Pediatrics found that over 70,000 children and teens go to emergency rooms annually for injuries and complications from medical devices. As a result of the 2008 Supreme Court decision in Riegel v. Medtronic, certain medical device manufacturers now have total immunity from liability. These manufacturers now have no financial incentive to either produce safe products, or recall unsafe devices, leaving thousands of Americans at risk. The Pediatrics study reported that the percentage of injuries attributable these types of devices is small, but the injuries tend to be the most serious and expensive to treat. They include many catheters, pacemakers and artificial joints.

The Medical Device Safety Act ("MDSA"), is a pending bipartisan bill, designed to reverse the devastating impact of the Riegel decision. The legislation is simple – the bill in its entirety runs less than two pages in length. Passage of the MDSA will restore the long-standing right of injured consumers to hold negligent medical device manufacturers accountable when their products cause injury and death. Learn more about the MDSA, and the patients it would help, by watching AFJ’s short documentary film, Hit and Run.

Medical device companies are lobbying hard to stop the MDSA, and have succeeded in stalling any committee action. With Pediatrics documenting so many potentially serious injuries of implantable devices, it's imperative that Congress restore the rights to the young victims' families and pass the MDSA without further unwarranted delay.

Friday, May 21, 2010

For Medtronic, big profits from less jobs and no liability

Medtronic announced a downsizing of 600 jobs in Minnesota, and 1800 worldwide. Overall, at least two-thirds of losses worldwide are in the US. Similar cuts in the last two years have brought a net loss of 500 Minnesota jobs. Despite the company's likely distribution of $900 million in shareholder dividends this year, workers and employees continue to suffer. After the Supreme Court ruling in Riegel v. Medtronic, patients injured by faulty implants and defibrillators manufactured by Medtronic can find no recourse in the courts.

The ruling in Riegel from 2008 is part of a larger trend of rulings that put the interests of big corporations ahead of individuals and consumers. Since Chief Justice Roberts joined the Court, it has taken a much larger number of business cases, from antitrust to securities to shareholder suits – and its sympathy to big business is striking. Forty percent of the cases heard every year by the Roberts Court involve or are significant to big business, up from 30% at the end of Chief Justice Rehnquist’s tenure.

The Supreme Court’s pro-corporate shift is the result of a conservative court packing effort that began during the Reagan administration. A coalition of big business special interest groups engaged in a comprehensive campaign to elevate corporate profits and private wealth over individual rights and personal freedoms as the cornerstones of our legal process. The fruits of their labor have now ripened: of the 30 business cases heard in the 2006-07 term, 22 were decided unanimously in favor of big business, or with just one or two dissenting votes, and against the interests of everyday Americans. In the same term, the conservative U.S. Chamber of Commerce prevailed in 13 out of the 15 cases in which it filed friend-of-the-court briefs representing corporate interests, it highest winning percentage in its 30-year history.

While the Supreme Court may be ruling overwhelmingly in favor of big business at the expense of ordinary Americans, Congress can take action to correct its wrongs . Speedy passage of the Medical Device Safety Act (MDSA), will correct the decision in Riegel v. Medtronic and stop medical device companies from continuing to avoid liability for faulty devices.
Help force Medtronic to put patients before profits: sign our petition urging Congress to pass MDSA.

Monday, March 22, 2010

Food and Drug Administration Improvement Act of 2010

We are pleased to see that Rep. Maurice Hinchey (D-NY) has introduced legislation designed to correct some of the problems in the FDA governing framework. Congress must take action to help the FDA fulfill its mission of protecting the public safety, since consumers cannot ask the courts to protect them from faulty medical devices.

As a result of the Supreme Court’s 2008 ruling in Riegel v. Medtronic, thousands of victims of faulty medical devices are denied their day in court and left unable to recoup damages for medical expenses or pain and suffering. Take for example Avery deGroh. Born with a hereditary heart defect called Long QT Syndrome, Avery received a surgically implanted defibrillator at age two. One year later, Avery’s defibrillator began sending unnecessary electric shocks to her heart, and a terrified Avery believed that monsters were attacking her. Avery’s mother, Molly, held her helpless daughter as the device fired nine times, causing Avery intense pain.

Doctors deactivated the device, and Avery underwent another surgery to replace the defibrillator with a new unit from a different manufacturer. Years later, Avery’s parents are still struggling to pay for the $30,000 cost of surgery, which was not covered by insurance or Medtronic, the manufacturer of the defective device.

What the Avery’s parents did not know at the time of surgery was that Medtronic had received other reports of shocks in patients. Medtronic ultimately revealed that 2,200 people were injured and thirteen killed as a result of its defective product. Because of Riegel v. Medtronic, none of the people injured are able to bring claims against Medtronic for the harm it caused.

Help end corporate immunity for medical device manufacturers: sign our petition urging Congress to pass the Medical Device Safety Act.

Friday, February 26, 2010

$900 Million in Dividends, Nothing for the Injured

Last week, the FDA announced that it lacks critical powers of oversight over medical devices submitted using the “510(k)” or “Pre-Market Notification” (PMN) process, and that it may go to Congress to request additional regulatory authority.

For the last 35 years, the FDA has annually approved approximately 3,500 devices using a 35-year-old law from Section 510(k) of the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act. 510(k) allows the FDA to determine whether a new medical device is substantially equivalent to a device previously approved, in which case it will be quickly cleared for release onto the market. The program is popular among medical device manufacturers because it is expedient: only 50 or so devices are approved annually under the more rigorous FDA approval system. According to the Government Accountability Office, 20 high risk devices later discovered to be dangerous to consumers were mistakenly passed through the FDA under the 510(k) system last year.

In related news, last week the FDA lifted restrictions on Medtronic external defibrillators, saying that the company had met quality control requirements and could again begin unrestricted shipment worldwide. Medtronic then announced a fourth quarter dividend of $0.205 per share. Medtronic shareholders are on pace to receive over $900 million in dividends this year, while the victims of its faulty devices find their legal claims against the company preempted by FDA approval, and have no legal recourse to recover damages for medicals bills, lost wages, or pain and suffering.

Consumers have faced multiple surgeries due to faulty orthopedic implants, or found themselves shocked by faulty defibrillator leads. However, upon bringing suit, consumers have then found their legal rights nullified by the device’s prior approval by an agency that concedes it lacks the authority necessary to ensure public safety. Circumstances demand speedy legislative action to correct these injustices: passage of the Medical Device Safety Act (MDSA). MDSA would protect consumers’ right to sue when they are harmed by certain defective medical products. As Dr. Larry Kessler, a 13-year veteran of the FDA device center, points out, “The device world codified by the Medical Device Amendments of 1976 is dramatically different than where we are today 35 years later. The pace of innovation has really ramped up and the 510(k) process has been used, and in some cases people would say misused, to clear very advanced technology.”

Help hold device manufacturers accountable: sign our petition urging Congress to pass the Medical Device Safety Act.

Thursday, February 18, 2010

AFJ Filmmakers Nominated for an Oscar

Congratulations to filmmakers Jon Alpert and Matt O'Neill on the Oscar nomination for their HBO documentary Unnatural Disaster: The Tears of Sichuan Province!

Alliance for Justice is proud to have recently partnered with Jon and Matt to produce two short documentaries explaining why people harmed by prescription drugs or defective medical devices need to access justice through our courts. The films Hit and Run and Access Denied: the Fight for Corporate Accountability tell the story of Americans who trusted pharmaceutical and medical device manufacturers to sell safe products, were harmed as a result, and now have no ability to seek recourse for their damages. The films explain why Congress must pass the Medical Device Safety Act, which is desperately needed to end corporate immunity for manufacturers of faulty medical devices.

We hope people will take action and join with the AARP, The New England Journal of Medicine, Public Citizen, Easter Seals, the National Conference for State Legislatures, and a number of other medical and consumer advocacy groups to pass the Medical Device Safety Act in 2010.

Thanks to Jon and Matt for helping Alliance for Justice bring attention to FDA preemption and the Medical Device Safety Act, and best of luck to you at this year’s Oscars!

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Protecting Patients from Defective Medical Devices

On August 4, patients from across the country who have been harmed by defective medical devices will travel to attend a hearing in front of the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions. The 2:30 PM hearing, entitled “Protecting Patients from Defective Medical Devices” will be preceded by a press conference from 12:00 - 1:00 PM in the Russell Senate building room 485.

Alliance for Justice President Nan Aron will open the press conference, with Senator Harkin (D-IA) and several medical device patients speaking about why Congress must quickly take action to pass the Medical Device Safety Act of 2009. The event will also feature a screening of AFJ's film “Hit and Run”. If you are interested in attending the press conference please contact Lisa Hayes at LHayes@afj.org or 202-822-6070.

Thursday, June 11, 2009

AFJ continues to push Congress to pass the Medical Device Safety Act

This morning the Campaign to Stop Corporate Immunity held a conference call that included a campaign update, as well as a short presentation from Alliance for Justice on Judge Sotomayor’s record on preemption. Jennifer Meinig, Legislative Counsel for AFJ, shared data from AFJ’s recently released report focusing on Judge Sotomayor’s access to justice cases. Judge Sotomayor has ruled on only a few preemption cases, but has exhibited a characteristically measured approach in her rulings. The decisions reflect a rigorous analysis and Judge Sotomayor delves deep into the facts of cases reflecting the complex interplay between state and federal law. Ms. Meinig gave a few examples of cases that typify Judge Sotomayor’s rulings involving preemption including, Protection & Advocacy for Persons with Disabilities v. Kirk, 448 F.3d 119 (2d Cir. 2006), Patient Protection & Advocacy, Inc. v. Houstoun, 228 F.3d 423 (3d Cir. 2000), and Empire Healthchoice Assurance v. McVeigh, 396 F.3d 136 (2d Cir. 2005). These cases, and others, are explored in detail in the Access to Justice report.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

We Need Medical Device Safety Now

The announcement on May 20 from Medtronic comes as a timely reminder of why we need the Medical Device Safety Act.

Medtronic’s announcement warns doctors that 37,000 of their pacemakers may be defective. This announcement comes after last week’s House Subcommittee Energy and Commerce hearing on "H.R. 1346, the Medical Device Safety Act of 2009." The 2008 Supreme Court decision Riegel v. Medtronic took away the rights of injured consumers to hold negligent medical device manufacturers accountable when their products cause injury and death. The Medical Device Safety Act will restore those rights allowing consumers such as Bill Storms, of Delaware, Ohio, to hold device manufacturers accountable.

From the Cleveland Plain Dealer
Two summers ago, Bill Storms of Delaware, Ohio, says he got 138 electrical jolts over a five-hour period when the wires to his pacemaker went haywire. The 38-year-old truck driver had to visit several emergency rooms before the device could be turned off.

"It felt like having a horse inside you trying to kick its way out of your chest," said Storms, whose lawsuit against the maker of his Sprint Fidelis pacemaker wires was thrown out of court this year along with hundreds of similar cases by a judge who cited a 2008 Supreme Court precedent.

Storms and others who say they were injured by faulty medical devices want Congress to pass legislation that would override the Supreme Court decision in Riegel v. Medtronic, which found that consumers can't sue medical device companies over medical devices that have been approved by the Food and Drug Administration.


You can help people like Bill Storms receive justice by urging Congress to pass the Medical Device Safety Act. Sign our petition to Protect our Health and Safety and Restore Corporate Accountability. You can learn more about the Medtronic case and other recent decisions on our Supreme Court Watch page.

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

@NanAron Tweeting Live from House Subcommittee Hearing

The House Subcommittee on Energy and Commerce is holding a hearing on "H.R. 1346, the Medical Device Safety Act of 2009." The hearing today at 2:00 p.m. features witnesses:

  • David Vladeck, J.D., Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center
  • William H. Maisel, M.D., M.P.H., Director, Medical Device Safety Institute, Department of Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston
  • Gregory Curfman, M.D., Editor, New England Journal of Medicine
  • Bridget Robb, Gwynedd, Pennsylvania
  • Richard Cooper, Partner, Williams & Connolly LLP
  • Michael Kinsley, Seattle, Washington

We will be giving live updates from the hearing via Twitter, so follow @NanAron for the latest news and information.

The Medical Device Safety Act, H.R. 1346, would overturn a 2008 Supreme Court decision that, for the first time, denied patients injured by certain medical devices the right to seek compensation through state product liability lawsuits.

Learn more about the Medical Device Safety Act and how you can help.